A WAY OUT OF THE MIRE IN SYRIA? PUTIN jUMPS ON KERRY SUGGESTION

Secretary of State John Kerry, in an off-the-cuff remark, said Assad could prevent military action if he gives up his chemical weapons.

N.Y. TIMES

President Obama on Monday tentatively embraced a Russian diplomatic proposal to avert a United States military strike on Syria by having international monitors take control of the Syrian government’s chemical weapons. The move added new uncertainty to Mr. Obama’s push to win support among allies, the American public and members of Congress for an attack.

DAILY MAIL

Last night the US government said it would take a ‘hard look’ at the Russian proposal but had ‘serious scepticism’ about putting Syria’s chemical weapons under international protection.
Mr Kerry’s intervention, made as he concluded a tour of Western nations, risked complicating a crunch vote in the US Senate over whether to back Barack Obama’s plans to use force against Syria.

N.Y. TIMES (Cont'd)

Mr. Obama’s statements about the haphazardly constructed plan appeared to offer him an exit strategy for a military strike he had been reluctant to order, and it came as support on Capitol Hill for a resolution authorizing force was slipping. Even some lawmakers who had announced support for it reversed course.

Senator Harry Reid of Nevada, the majority leader, said Monday evening that he would not force an initial vote on the resolution on Wednesday, slowing Senate consideration until at least next week. If President Obama fears losing the vote, some suspect he may yet use Mr Kerry’s intervention as a device to delay. Democrats said they had enough votes to overcome a filibuster but possibly not enough to pass it.

 

[ Reuters:   President Obama is going to have a steep climb to convince Americans it's worth attacking Syria. A new Reuters/Ipsos poll, conducted at the beginning of September, shows that 63 percent oppose intervening in the civil war. That's up from 53 percent who thought it was a bad idea at the end of August.]

DAILY MAIL (Cont'd)

Within hours, Russia seized on the idea. The country’s foreign minister Sergei Lavrov, following talks in Moscow with his Syrian counterpart Walid al-Moallem, said: ‘If the establishment of international control over chemical weapons in that country would allow avoiding strikes, we will immediately start working with Damascus.
‘We are calling on the Syrian leadership to not only agree on placing chemical weapons storage sites under international control, but also on its subsequent destruction and fully joining the treaty on prohibition of chemical weapons.’

N.Y. TIMES (Cont'd)

But to some, the offhand nature of Mr. Kerry’s comment and Moscow’s hurried response raised suspicions that the Russians and Syrians were making plans to control the chemical stockpile or were, at the least, using the proposal as a delaying tactic that could undermine Mr. Obama’s efforts for a military strike.       

Either way, the proposal did not appear to be one that Mr. Kerry or the Obama administration had intended.

 

The effort to police such a proposal, even if Syria agreed, would be a laborious and prolonged effort, especially since Mr. Assad’s government has shrouded its arsenal in secrecy for decades. As United Nations inspectors discovered in Iraq after the Persian Gulf war in 1991, even an invasive inspection program can take years to account for chemical stockpiles and never be certain of complete compliance, something that President George W. Bush used to justify the invasion of Iraq in 2003.

 

Syria’s foreign minister, Walid al-Moallem, who was in Moscow, welcomed Russia’s proposal, though he stopped short of pledging that Mr. Assad would comply. His remarks, however, tacitly acknowledged that Syria possessed a chemical arsenal, something it had never publicly done.

...Syria has maintained [the weapons] in large part as a deterrent to Israel, which is widely assumed to have a nuclear arsenal that it has never officially acknowledged.

 

 

Mr. Obama ...promised that his administration would engage with the Russians to see if the world could “arrive at something that is enforceable and serious.” But he said that “if we don’t maintain and move forward with a credible threat of military pressure, I do not think we will actually get the kind of agreement I would like to see.” ....He said that if Syrian officials accepted the Russian proposal, “then this could potentially be a significant breakthrough.”

 

[The Guardian:  U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said that a strike in Syria may be postponed until after a discussion by the United Nations Security Council next week. His comments come on the heels of key ally France saying that the nation will not act until after a report from the weapons inspectors—who were in Syria during the attack.]

 

 

AND THE OTHE OTHER IMPORTANT NEWS OF THE DAY: ZIMMERMAN  ARRESTED AND THEN RELEASED:

DAILY MAIL :

 
 Shellie Zimmerman (center) called police at 2pm on Monday, claiming George Zimmerman (left with a police officer) was at the Lake Mary, Florida home (right) belonging to her parents. The altercation was sparked by claims he had been having an affair with a former fiancee, friends told MailOnline. On a 911 call, Shellie is heard sobbing, claiming that her estranged husband punched her father in the nose and threatened to shoot them as he sat in his car. But she has not pressed charges and Zimmerman has been released. According to an Associated Press report, ...officers on Monday "didn't find anything that indicated he [Zimmerman] had a gun on his person." It comes just days after Shellie filed for divorce, claiming that their marriage was 'irretrievably broken' following the Trayvon Martin murder trial.

N.Y. DAILY NEWS

 In an interview with ABC News shown Friday, Shellie Zimmerman called her husband of six years “selfish” and said he believes he’s “invincible” after being found not guilty in the racially charged Trayvon Martin case. A friend of the feuding couple told the  N.Y. Daily News that tempers flew when Shellie Zimmerman accused George of having an affair.That’s probably what’s going on,” the friend, John Donnelly, who was called as a character witness for Zimmerman during his trial, told The News. “Shellie hasn’t even hardly seen him. Three or four days after the trial ended, he was gone.” Zimmerman [Donnelly said] has left those closest to him feeling 'angry and used' and how his affair with a former fiancee was the final straw for Shellie.

ZIMMERMAN AQUITTED IN SHOOTING-DEATH OF TRAYVON MARTIN

HUFFINGTON POST          N.Y. TIMES

After deliberating for more than 16 hours, a jury of six women on Saturday evening found George Zimmerman not guilty in the shooting death of Trayvon Martin, an unarmed 17-year-old in Sanford, Fla.
Zimmerman had pleaded not guilty to charges of second-degree murder with an affirmative defense, claiming he had shot Martin to save his own life after being attacked by the teen on Feb. 26, 2012. The death ignited a national debate on racial profiling and civil rights. The trial, televised nationally on cable networks and streamed live across the Internet on various sites, kept the country captivated awaiting a verdict on the tragic events that took place that rainy night.

Following three weeks of testimony, more than a dozen witnesses and a host of controversy, Zimmerman walked out of court a free man The six-woman jury rejected the prosecution’s contention that Mr. Zimmerman had deliberately pursued Mr. Martin because he assumed the hoodie-clad teenager was a criminal and instigated the fight that led to his death.       

 

Mr. Zimmerman said he shot Mr. Martin on Feb. 26, 2012, in self-defense after the teenager knocked him to the ground, punched him and slammed his head repeatedly against the sidewalk. In finding him not guilty of murder or manslaughter, the jury agreed that Mr. Zimmerman could have been justified in shooting Mr. Martin because he feared great bodily harm or death.

The jury had been sequestered since June 24.

 

The case first drew national attention during the 44 days the Sanford Police Department took to decide that Zimmerman should be arrested and charged with murder. During that tense period, protests were held across the country calling for Zimmerman's arrest. Those protests were buttressed by the controversy's strong presence across the Internet, with hashtags like #JusticeForTrayvon becoming mainstays on Twitter. Celebrities including LeBron James and his Miami Heat teammates and Jamie Foxx were photographed wearing hooded sweatshirts like Martin had been wearing the night he died.




That night, Martin was walking back to the home of his father's fiancee from a local 7-Eleven convenience store after purchasing a can of iced tea and a bag of Skittles. He was spotted by Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch volunteer, who thought Martin looked suspicious because of what he described as an unnaturally slow and meandering gait. Zimmerman called the police and proceeded to follow the teen through the Retreat at Twin Lakes, the gated community where Zimmerman lived and where Martin had been staying. A confrontation ensued, Zimmerman shot Martin, Martin died, and six weeks later, Zimmerman was arrested and charged with second-degree murder.

NYT:
The shooting brought attention to Florida’s expansive self-defense laws. The laws allow someone with a reasonable fear of great bodily harm or death to use lethal force, even if retreating from danger is an option. In court, the gunman is given the benefit of the doubt.

 

The outcry began after the police initially decided not to arrest Mr. Zimmerman, who is half-Peruvian, as they investigated the shooting. Mr. Martin, 17, had no criminal record and was on a snack run, returning to the house where he was staying as a guest.

Six weeks later, Mr. Zimmerman was arrested, but only after civil rights leaders championed the case and demonstrators, many wearing hoodies, marched in Sanford, Miami and elsewhere to demand action.

“Justice for Trayvon!” they shouted.       

The pressure prompted Gov. Rick Scott of Florida to remove local prosecutors from the case and appoint Ms. Corey, from Jacksonville. She ultimately charged Mr. Zimmerman with second-degree murder. The tumult also led to the firing of the Sanford police chief.

Huffington Post:

As attention around the case mounted before the trial, details emerged about the teenager and the man involved in the fatal confrontation.
It turned out this wasn't Zimmerman's first run-in with the law. He had previously been accused of domestic violence by a former girlfriend, and he had also previously been arrested for assaulting a police officer. More controversially, in July 2012, an evidence dump related to the investigation of Martin's death revealed that a younger female cousin of Zimmerman's had accused him of nearly two decades of sexual molestation and assault. In addition, she had accused members of Zimmerman's family, including his Peruvian-born mother, of being proudly racist against African Americans, and recalled a number of examples of perceived bigotry.

The national focus on the case also brought into question, for some, the character and life history of Trayvon Martin. As time passed, websites like The Daily Caller found Martin's posthumously scrubbed Twitter page, which featured the teen at times tweeting profanities and showing off fake gold teeth. To some, these behaviors, along with the hoodie Martin wore the night he was killed, were an indication that he was something other than an innocent teenage boy who was shot while walking home from the store. To others, the attention paid to Martin's tattoos, gold teeth and hoodie were symptomatic of the same kind of stereotyping and profiling that led to Zimmerman's assumption that the teen was "up to no good."

While much of this background information proved inadmissible at trial, the characterizations of the two men helped drive an often racially charged polarization on the issue at the heart of the case -- whether the killing of Trayvon Martin was self-defense or murder.

NYT:
From the start, prosecutors faced a difficult task in proving second-degree murder. That charge required Mr. Zimmerman to have evinced a “depraved mind,” brimming with ill will, hatred, spite or evil intent, when he shot Mr. Martin.

Manslaughter, which under Florida law is typically added as a lesser charge if either side requests it, was a lower bar. Jurors needed to decide only that Mr. Zimmerman put himself in a situation that culminated in Mr. Martin’s death.

 

But because of Florida’s laws, prosecutors had to persuade jurors beyond a reasonable doubt that Mr. Zimmerman did not act in self-defense. A shortage of evidence in the case made that a high hurdle, legal experts said

Even after three weeks of testimony, the fight between Mr. Martin and Mr. Zimmerman on that rainy night was a muddle, fodder for reasonable doubt. It remained unclear who had started it, who screamed for help, who threw the first punch and at what point Mr. Zimmerman drew his gun. There were no witnesses to the shooting.
----
In 2011, Twin Lakes, the neighborhood of tidy town homes had been hit by a series of burglaries, and residents were concerned. That is when Mr. Zimmerman called Ms. Dorival, a community leader,  to set up a neighborhood watch program. At a presentation for about 25 residents in September 2011, Ms. Dorival outlined the rules.

She described residents as “the eyes and ears” of the police and said she encouraged them to report anything suspicious but keep a safe distance.

“We tell them not to confront,” Ms. Dorival added. “They are not supposed to take measures into their own hands.”

-----

Mr. Zimmerman, studied criminal justice in college, but did not complete the program.       

Prosecutors have sought to portray Mr. Zimmerman as so zealous about safety that he took sole control of the neighborhood watch program.

The president of the homeowners’ association, Don O’Brien, testified that Mr. Zimmerman came to him with the idea.

“He was running it,” he said of Mr. Zimmerman.
----
Mr. Zimmerman, the prosecutors said, was so concerned about burglaries in his townhouse complex that when he spotted Mr. Martin, an unfamiliar face in the rain, he immediately “profiled” him as a criminal. He picked up his phone and reported him to the police.       

Then he made the first in a string of bad choices, they said. He got out of the car with a gun on his waist; he disregarded a police dispatcher’s advice not to follow Mr. Martin and he chased the teenage, engaged in a fight and shot him in the heart.     

 

To stave off an arrest, he lied to the police, prosecutors said, embellishing his story to try to flesh out his self-defense claim.

“Punks,” Mr. Zimmerman said to the police dispatcher after he spotted Mr. Martin, adding a profanity. “They always get away,” he said at another point in the conversation, a reference to would-be burglars.

On these words, prosecutors hung their case of ill will, hatred and spite toward Mr. Martin.

“This defendant was sick and tired of it,” Bernie de la Rionda, the chief prosecutor, said in his closing statement. “He was going to be what he wanted to be — a police officer.”

Huffington Post:

The defense maintained that Zimmerman was just walking back to his car when Martin confronted him, punching him in his face and knocking him to the ground. According to the defense, Martin then mounted Zimmerman and smashed his head into the concrete pavement multiple times, forcing the older man to shoot the teen in order to save his own life.

NYT

But no one saw the shooting; witnesses saw and heard only parts of the struggle, and provided conflicting accounts.

And there was not a “shred of evidence” that Mr. Zimmerman was not returning to his car when Mr. Martin “pounced,” defense lawyers said.

Huffington Post::
Testimony at the trial was, at times, contentious. Defense attorney Don West aggressively questioned Rachel Jeantel, the friend to whom Martin was talking on the phone just before he was killed. Jeantel, who speaks English as a second language, kept her answers tersely short and stuck to her understanding of what had transpired that night, despite the defense's attempts to undermine her account. Her perceived lack of polish on the stand, though, thrust the teenager into a national conversation about whether she had hurt or helped the state's case.




NYT:
The prosecution’s witnesses did not always help their case. Ms. Jeantel, 19-years-old,  proved problematic. Her testimony was critical for the prosecution because she said that Mr. Martin was being followed by Mr. Zimmerman — a “creepy-ass cracker,” he called him — and that he was scared.

But Ms. Jeantel might have damaged her credibility by ...[her explanations of why] she did not attend Mr. Martin’s wake. She also testified that she softened her initial account of her chat with Mr. Martin for fear of upsetting Ms. Fulton, Trayvon's mother,  who sat next to her, weeping, during Ms. Jeantel’s first interview with prosecutors.

 

She did not miss the wake because she was in the hospital, as she said at first, but because she did not want to see Mr. Martin’s body.

“You don’t know how it felt,” she told Mr. West. “You think I really want to see the body after I just talked to him?”

Ms. Jeantel said she did not realize Mr. Martin had died until two days later when friends at school told her. She did not call the police then because she expected the police to call her, the way they do on “The First 48,” a reality police show.

===

Proving a less-than-stellar witness, Ms. Jeantel said she had been reluctant to get involved in the case because it was so emotional. She said the first time she spoke under oath was in front of Mr. Martin's anguished mother, which prompted her to soften her statements.
----
Typically, police testimony boosts the state’s case. Here, the chief police investigator, Chris Serino, told jurors that he believed Mr. Zimmerman, despite contradictions in his statements.

Through it all, though, the defense chipped away at the prosecution’s case. The resident with the best vantage point of the fight described a “ground and pound” fight, with a person in red or a light color on the bottom. Mr. Zimmerman wore a reddish jacket.       

And a prominent forensic pathologist who is an expert in gunshot wounds testified that the trajectory of the bullet was consistent with Mr. Martin leaning over Mr. Zimmerman when the gun was fired.

Both the prosecution and the defense went to great lengths to show who was screaming for help in the background of that 911 call. The prosecution called Trayvon Martin's mother, Sybrina Fulton, and his brother, Jahvaris Fulton, who testified that it was Martin. The defense called George Zimmerman's mother, father and a host of friends to testify that it was Zimmerman screaming.

The defense also had one piece of irrefutable evidence, photographs of Mr. Zimmerman’s injuries — a bloody nose along with lumps and two cuts on his head. It indicated that there had been a fight and that Mr. Zimmerman had been harmed, and the defense showed them to the jury at every opportunity.